MovieChat Forums > Winona Ryder Discussion > Winona Ryder accuses Mel Gibson of makin...

Winona Ryder accuses Mel Gibson of making anti-semitic and homophobic remarks


https://www.chicagotribune.com/entertainment/ct-ent-winona-ryder-mel-gibson-20200623-dzogjdtwdzhubdrdhum2im3w2q-story.html

reply

Too easy to say those things now. I sincerely doubt Gibson would have had a career in Hollywood if he made jokes like that.

Miss Winona's also forgetting that she's a convicted criminal herself.

reply

Mel Gibson has done more shit than Winona Ryder.

I'm not giving Mel Gibson any excuse but I think in his day a lot of people openly said stuff like that, don't think they thought anything of it, if you which a 80's movie like Lethal Weapon they used to talk shit about blacks or gays, times have changed, this kind of talk in the 21st Century has stopped being acceptable.

reply

times have changed, this kind of talk in the 21st Century has stopped being acceptable.

To whom?

reply

Now days people are more political correct and Australia was known for being racist.

reply

What's Australia have to do with anything?

reply

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Racism_in_Australia

reply

I can only repeat, What's Australia got to do with it? Are you Australian?

reply

Mel Gibson grow up in Australia from the age of 12, so that's probably where his bigotry comes from.

reply

Frankly, you sound a bit bigoted against Australians. I know a couple of Aussies, and I've never found them to be bigoted or racist or whatever.

reply

And this makes you very knowledgeable on this subject. Brava.

reply

from my travels i found them to be very racist by today's standards. in a good way tho they are very funny about it at least

reply

Mel Gibson's dad is a bigot, and particularly hates Jews and is a Holocaust denier. THAT'S where Mel got it from. It tended to come out more when he was drunk.

Sadly, given all of today's antisemitism, it looks like Mel was just ahead of his time.

reply

You mean diversity induced between group conflict in Australia?

reply

Ryder got 3 years probation, community service and a large fine for theft, shoplifting and vandalism. Gibson has been arrested twice for driving under the influence. Is that really "more shit"?

Maybe he would've gotten away with talk like that about black people and women. But there are a lot of Jewish and gay folks in Hollywood, I don't think they would very much appreciate him talking like that. Just see how his career went downhill after The Passion of the Christ and that altercation during his arrest.



reply

Driving under the influence could certainly cause more lasting damage, such as injury and death.

reply

But has he done "more shit"?

reply

Lethal Weapon 2 the racists were the bad guys. There was a whole scene where Murtagh went to the South African consul building to apply for migration there to cause a diversion.

The South African desk clerk questions him applying, why?

>Because you are Blick

Then we are supposed to laugh, like look at those racists and look how great 'murica is. Look how evolved we are here.

Meanwhile 2020 black dudes are getting choked out by cops for nothing and racist people are going nuts because someone has a black lives matter sticker on their car.

reply

It's not the first time she has spoken of the encounter. She also mentioned it in a GQ interview in 2010.

I completely believe that Ryder is telling the truth, but I don't think this means Gibson should be "cancelled". Ryder's statement suggests neither does she:

"I believe in redemption and forgiveness and hope that Mr. Gibson has found a healthy way to deal with his demons, but I am not one of them. Around 1996, my friend Kevyn Aucoin and I were on the receiving end of his hateful words. It is a painful and vivid memory for me. Only by accepting responsibility for our behavior in this life, can we make amends and truly respect each other, and I wish him well on this lifelong journey.”

Seriously, is there a single living person who isn't aware that Gibbo can be a bit of a dick? I choose not to concern myself with his private life or personal attitudes and enjoy him for the charismatic movie star and talented film maker he is.

reply

Ryder has also said that she thinks she's married to Keanu Reeves. I take everything she says with a grain of salt. Even if some kind of comment was made by Gibson, I think it's very likely she's exaggerating or that it's just hearsay.

I absolutely believe Gibson is a dick and I don't even enjoy him much as an actor. At the same time I also believe that Ryder has a lot of issues of her own. We've been hearing a lot about this has-been lately.

reply

I don't know. I like them both.

reply

Not a fan of either, although I've probably enjoyed Ryder's movies more. But considering her own past transgressions and her sermon about forgiveness and redemption, it's hypocritical of her to still bring this up 25 years later. Seems like the lady wants to jump on the bandwagon and chose an easy target to do so.

reply

Yeah, maybe. It's not as if she retold the story unprompted though, she was asked by a reporter if she had ever experienced antisemitism in Hollywood and she mentioned something she had already discussed a decade prior. It's a bit different to the current tactic of getting on social media to slam someone you have a beef with, which to me would be more opportunistic than answering an interview question honestly.

Not sure if I'm down with equating shoplifting to hate speech either, but I understand neither of them are angels. I guess at the end of the day all this means is we won't be seeing Mel and Winona starring in a film together. Which is a shame when you think about it, I would definitely pay to see that movie.

reply

Meh, I wouldn't call two bad jokes made under the influence at some party "hate speech". It's not a criminal offence, as opposed to shoplifting and vandalism.

One can always choose to avoid answering such questions. No doubt she expected the question, there usually is some kind of agreement between the reporter and the celebrity being interviewed. And she's been making similar comments recently.

20 Years ago people thought it would be a good idea to put Winona and Richard Gere together in a movie, so I'm not so sure...😬

reply

Sure, if that's the only time Mel had slipped up. There was the whole phone call to his partner where he screamed that he hopes she is "raped by a pack of n*ggers", the anti-Jewish slurs to his arresting officers, his many disparaging remarks about gays... it's quite a pattern of behaviour.

You're right though, Winona could have left that story in the past. I do believe she is within her rights to talk about it, but in the end it doesn't really achieve much other than clearly enraging Gibson.

Oh well, it'll all blow over in a few days once there is another outrageous celebrity statement or feud to draw focus.

reply

Gibson has a serious drinking problem. Still, those incidents were not criminal and between him and the people he offended. Hate speech is something else. I think him drinking and driving is a much more serious offence.

No doubt it will blow over, but the next time might be another comment from Winona. It's just another way for has-beens to get attention. Maybe Mel can save his career by claiming Kevin Spacey touched his leg without asking.🤷‍♀️

reply

Yes. Who cares what that convicted thief has to say about Mel Gibson?

reply

Who cares what a convicted thief has to say against a liar and serial philanderer.

Fixed it for you.

reply

It was at a party. I've been to parties with Jewish people who made self-derogatory and very Anti-Semitic jokes as well being on the receiving end of Jew Jokes like someone spilling a bunch of coins on the floor to see their reactions.

If Mel had done this outside of a party setting and not under the influence then I'd probably feel differently, but it was a party where he and probably herself was pretty coked up.

Also, why didn't she name the Jewish movie exec who said she too pretty and at the same time "too Jewish looking" to play a WASPy heroine.

reply

Agree. Party is where people make fun of each other. I guess a proper response to his "oven" joke is “You are getting too wasted to dodge the bullet from the Squads."

BTW, Winona Ryder is not Jewish. (source: http://www.isjewish.com/winona_ryder/)

reply

Ryder is just desperately trying to make herself relevant again. Please.

reply

Keep in mind that Mel Gibson although born in America grew up in Sydney, Australia from the age of 12 in 1968. Sydney is notorious for it's abrasive and hard boiled sense of humour and those were the days before political correctness. It can be quite a shock to the system for people who are not used to it.


reply

There were curtain things they could get away with saying. Now in the 21st Century we are sort of getting better with each other.

reply

Lmao you say that while the US is burning down and more obsessed with race than ever.

reply

Fake news. I have a hard time believing anything anymore.

reply

I knew this ages ago. Obviously "cancel culture" is the in thing in 2020, so obviously the American media decides to bring it back this year and starts making a big deal about it. American media really are bottom feeders.

reply

yes this was brought up at least twice in the last 20 something years. love her and love mel gibson.

reply