MovieChat Forums > John Wayne Discussion > The Duke or The Draft Dodger?

The Duke or The Draft Dodger?


The most balanced article I found. It leaves whether Wayne or the studio was responsible as unknown.

https://www.warhistoryonline.com/instant-articles/john-wayne-the-duke.html

At first, Wayne was exempted from military service due to his family status and his age. He was 34 at the time and had a wife and four kids to support.

Several other stars, however, joined the ranks despite having a family to support. Henry Fonda, Gene Autry, Jimmy Stewart, Clark Gable, and Robert Montgomery had all enlisted themselves in spite of having similar circumstances to that of Wayne.

Ronald Reagan, who had also recently got his breakthrough movie King’s Row in 1942, joined the service for the military signal corps, declining several potentially big movies. Many fellow celebrities voluntarily enlisted themselves. As a result, it didn’t take long for Wayne to become the center of controversy.

Despite being close friends who remained deeply connected for almost their entire careers, a sore point was always there between Wayne and Ford due to Wayne’s failure to serve in the military. He also got into several fights with servicemen during the war because of his alleged “draft dodging.”

Since Wayne’s death, there has been an extensive debate on whether his absence from the war was justified or whether he was just a draft dodging hypocrite. We can probably never know for sure what kept him from joining the ranks. This knowledge is something he took with him to his grave.

reply

He was much more useful for 🇺🇸 making movies and heading bond drives. This kept up morale and fighting spirit for the USA.

To have John Wayne and Bob Hope in the trenches dodging bullets is a incredible waste of talent.

reply

That's an argument you can make to keep all the actors listed out of the armed forces. You could even twist it to state they were selfish to join up and should have stayed home.
But the hard fact is that Wayne's career thrived in the absence of the established stars and this doesn't sit well with his later films and politics.

reply

John Wayne is not all actors

In war time a manly man is needed to adequately depict 🇺🇸 strength and vitality.

John Wayne was that man. Stewart and Fonda were too wirey, Flynn was too much of a playboy.

Other actors have a legitimate gripe, but were failing to see the big picture, and probably a little jealous of Wayne's success.

reply

Neither Gable nor Stewart had kids then.

reply

Wayne tried to enlist but was turned down.

reply

I think that the only ones who can look down on Wayne for not serving in the military are those who have served in the military themselves.

Today, almost all of us are draft dodgers.

reply

Well, he definitely wasn't a draft dodger. His draft card which shows that he did report is public record and available to see.

reply