Never won an Oscar


It still amazes me the late great Sir Alfred Hitchcock never won an Oscar for best director, and for much of it I blame the supremely talented Billy Wilder!!!

Hitchcock was nominated for only five of his films, them being: Rebecca (1940), Lifeboat (1944), Spellbound (1945), Rear Window (1954) and Psycho (1960).

For Rebecca he lost out to John Ford’s The Grapes of Wrath, which is understandable. With Lifeboat he lost out to Leo McCarey’s forgettable Bing Crosby film Going My Way, Billy Wilder for Double Indemnity was also nominated that year.

Billy Wilder triumphed over Hitchcock the following year with a satire, The Lost Weekend beating Spellbound for best director.

Hitchcock had to wait nine years until he was nominated again, this time for Rear Window, which lost to On the Waterfront directed by Elia Kazan, who was a worthy winner.

And again in 1960 Hitchcock’s Psycho lost to Billy Wilder’s comedy The Apartment.

Two of Wilder’s films beat Hitchcock for best director, and the kick in the teeth is that they aren’t his best or most remembered films, in total Wilder won six Oscars, the others being for screenplay. Hitchcock won none.

I’m not bashing Wilder at all, as he directed some true classics such as, Some Like It Hot, Double Indemnity and Sunset Boulevard, not to mention his many writing credits.

And of the meagre amount of films Hitchcock was nominated for, Lifeboat really should of won. But what about his other classics such as North by Northwest, Vertigo, Marnie, The Birds, and To Catch a Thief, to name but a few - not one of them nominated for best director.

When it came to the Oscars, Alfred Hitchcock really was the Wrong Man! 🤨

reply

Oscars=shit

reply

Your math seems accurate to me.

reply

Yes, and it's not even a difficult equation, quite an obvious one indeed.
Only most people lack basic knowledge, so they cannot see it.

reply

They did honor him with the Irving G. Thalberg Memorial Award.

reply

[deleted]

The Oscars are a clown show.

reply

They are now and have been for decades, I totally agree!

reply

yes, 9 decades.

reply

If he was American he would have won.

reply

Hitchcock had different problems at the Oscars in different years.

But by the fifties and sixties, his biggest problem was: he was too successful. Too much the showman. And most irritatingly to film people: he was a giant TV star -- TV was the enemy of many in the film world.

Yes, they GAVE him the Thalberg in 1968, but he never WON the award as so valued "from his peers"(voting; the Academy leadership alone decided on the Thalberg.)

Also, clearly Hitchcock didn't make "Oscar bait movies." Thrillers were "looked down on," like Westerns. Its telling that while Hitchcock managed to get Best Director nominations for Rear Window and Psycho, neither film got a Best Picture nomination(which, back then, pretty much killed Hitchcocks chances to get Best Director.)

Though he's hardly alone, I think Hitchcock is at the top of the list of Academy embarrassments: A Motion Picture Academy of Arts and Sciences that never gave Hitchcock the Best Director award...isn't REALLY a Motion Picture Academy of Arts and Sciences at all.

And for which films did he DESERVE the Oscar?

I think that both Rear Window and Psycho derserved Picture and Director...over On the Waterfront and The Apartment(great films too, but not as great as the Hitchcocks that year.)

And the Hitchcock movie that REALLY got snubbed in lots of categories was: Psycho.

I think Psycho should have won:

Best Picture
Best Actor(Anthony Perkins)
Best Actress(Janet Leigh -- really nominated for Best Supporting Actress, but she should have been nominated for Best Actress.)
Best Director (Hitchcock, who was nominated)
Best Musical Score(Bernard Herrmann)
Best Film Editing(for the SHOWER SCENE!)
Best b/wArt Direction(for that HOUSE, nominated there)
Best b/w Cinematography(nominated there)

and at least nominations(if not wins) for:

Best Supporting Actor(Martin Balsam as Detective Arbogast)
Joseph Stefano(Best Adapted Screenplay)

The Academy really dropped the ball on Psycho...

reply

Its staggering Psycho won zilch, for me it remains his best film with great performances, direction, film editing and musical score. It couldn’t even win cinematography when black and white and colour were separated! 😑

Of all the films nominated that year, I’d say Psycho and Spartacus remain the most remembered among the general public, that’s some achievement at least.

reply