MovieChat Forums > Judy Garland Discussion > MGM's crazy diet for her

MGM's crazy diet for her


According to an article in Marie Claire last year, the big brass had her on a restricted diet of cottage cheese and chicken soup. They even reprimanded her for enjoying a rare sundae! In addition, the article stated the teen smoked up to 80 cigarettes a day. That is truly messed up!

reply

Judy Garland was an abuse victim - by her mother, Hollywood executives, and Big Pharma. Makes me sick.

reply

Judy Garland was an abuse victim - by her mother, Hollywood executives, and Big Pharma. Makes me sick.[/quote]
BINGO !

[quote]In addition, the article stated the teen smoked up to 80 cigarettes a day. That is truly messed up!


Judy was given "uppers" for energy and weight loss. Then, "downers" to counteract the "uppers."

The dangers weren't well known at the time, and it was standard practice for many performers. If anyone did suspect the dangers, they didn't give a damn. She was big box office, and they were milking her for everything they could get out of her.

As for the cigarettes, dangers weren't known in the 30's and 40's. Look any movie from that period, and they all smoked like chimneys.

reply

The same with musicians, Motown legends Mary Welles and Eddie Kendricks, as well as ex- Beatle George Harrison died from lung cancer.

reply

oh my.. that's a lotta smokes.

reply

Things aren't much better for young actresses today, except that today the studio heads don't give orders to the studio commissary regarding what they are allowed to serve a certain actress. The pressure to stay well below their natural weight is still there.

No, today's actresses are able to choose what food they don't eat, all by themselves!

reply

I agree, even today the studios go to far. But this anything goes authentic movement is ridiculous as well. I like seeing performers and models looking their best, with makeup and trim physiques in fabulous clothes. But it's only fantasy to me,plus it's their job. I also think the studios need reform in regards to caring for their emotional and physical health as wel l. But sadly, money does talk.



reply

When it comes to employing minors, I'd say the studios and entertainment conglomerates have an official "duty of care", and that includes refraining from starving their young moneymakers or giving them "pep pills" (or employing Dan Schneider). But in the 1930s when Garland was young, child labor was still legal and so was Dexedrine, and look how Mickey and Judy turned out.

As to your other point, I agree that I like to see celebrities looking their best, and I enjoy the red carpets of Awards Season as much as anyone. But one of the things I enjoy about it is seeing how a variety of humans dress to the nines, not just the ones with model-perfect looks. I mean, a regular person with regular looks can't really learn anything about fashion from watching the models, they get the big bucks because they're capable of looking good in anything and making anything look good! No, in addition to the perfect young things, I want to see how the veteran actors or the behind-the-scenes pros or the kids dress, it's more interesting.

reply

I have a good friend who was a network TV producer who saw Judy in concert, I think in Philadelphia. The poor woman was so intoxicated that she fell off the stage. My friend rushed to her. She said that, when she reached Judy, she was writhing on the ground and crying, “God, please let me die.” I do not know how anyone could not have his/her heart just go right out to such a gifted spirit who was in so much pain. Judy Garland was a Gift to the world.

I had the privilege of seeing her daughter, Liza, in concert with
Ben Vereen and The Radio City Music Hall Rockettes at Boston’s Symphony Hall at Christmastime long ago. No matter how good an audio or video recording may be, it cannot come close to live entertainment, and that give-and-take between the performers and the audience, just as there is no substitute for being in bed with your lover. Ben Vereen performed first. He was just coming off his Broadway run in Pippen. We gave him a standing ovation. He applauded us in the audience back! And said, “Liza is just going to eat you all up!” You CAN’T get that off a recording.

reply

A lot of young women went through MGM from the 1920s through the 1950s, and the great majority of them did not end up deranged and dead in their forties. There was something mentally wrong with Garland in the first place. As for smoking four packs a day, everybody in the 1940s knew that was unhealthy. That's why cigarettes were referred to as "coffin nails". In school in the 1960s, I saw an educational film from 1948 about smoking and lung cancer. People didn't respond to this knowledge as much back then because they hadn't been beaten over the head with it day in and day out the way we have been for the past fifty years.

reply

Is that film on You Tube? I enjoy vintage educational films. I am an 80's teen, now those films are vintage!

reply

A lot of young women went through MGM from the 1920s through the 1950s, and the great majority of them did not end up deranged and dead in their forties. There was something mentally wrong with Garland in the first place.


She most likely was manic/depressive, and they didn't have the knowledge or medications to deal with it in those days.

Garland seemed to lack the ability to pull herself up by the bootstraps. Why, I don't know. (It's true that doing the same things over and over and expecting different results is akin to insanity.)

However, contributing to this was being robbed by husbands, managers, and trusting the wrong people. As a young person at MGM (where they got her hooked on uppers and downers), everything was done for her -- or she was TOLD what to do. The studio system was like a parent. (It's been written that her own mother had her on medications before MGM, or was a willing participant with MGM.)

In her formative years, I don't think she ever learned (or had to learn) how to be responsible in life. She was allowed to coast on her talent. She didn't seem to want to take responsibility, because she never really had to.

MGM was all-controlling. All her decisions were made for her. Maybe she liked it that way.
She never had a chance to learn the life skills that we all are faced with as teenagers and adolescents. (Handling money, for example. The money was always there -- till it wasn't!)

Even in her music, I get the impression that she didn't want to learn anything new, relying on the tried and true. Go through her discography, and how many times did she record the same songs? (She even joked in concert, about singing new material.) Yet, in her youth, they say she was a very quick study.

All very difficult to figure out. For one so gifted, it's beyond sad, the way she wound up.

reply

She was 48 when she died and looked like she was a senior citizen by then.

reply

I know, it was sad. Her emotional and substance abuse demons really wrecked havoc on her appearance. She was not the only one. Look how badly David Cassidy looked in his final years. As well as other celebs over the decades.

reply


Cassidy was another one who burned his candle at both ends and even singed the middle a bit. His old man was a fall down drunk and I guess he thought he'd be like daddy.

reply

I was only 3 when the PF premiered on TV in 1970, but I liked the reruns as a kid. I watched all seasons on DVD last year, that was fun. His brother Shaun has aged well. I heard about how Jack Cassidy resented his family's fame, and his coldness towards David.

reply