MovieChat Forums > General Discussion > Squirrel vs rat

Squirrel vs rat


Is it bad to drown a rat that has been nesting in or around your house causing damage ?

Is it any different drowning a squirrel doing the same thing ?

reply

Interesting question.
Kill ALL Rats.

I had to kill a rat in my old Yonkers home after the stupid city dug up my street for a drainage project and the asshole geniuses in charge stirred the diseased little bastards up.
Every house on the block got a rat or two because some morons in City Hall decided drainage on a hillside neighborhood was of the utmost importance. Fuck the government, local, state and federal.

I set a large snap trap and snapped the rat by the neck in my kitchen. I had to toss it out into the alley and stomp it dead with my boot. Rats are tough critters, they don’t die easy.

I’d sometimes get squirrels up in the eaves of my attics, I had two houses at the time, they would try to make nests up there under the shingles. I like squirrels very much but I admit that I’ve shot two particularly stubborn ones that wouldn’t knock it off with their burglary schemes.

A couple of air gun .177 hunter pellets will do for a pesky squirrel but I tended to use a Havaheart Trap and they work just fine. You trap the squirrel and dump it a mile away in a parkland. Alive.

I hate rats and have no problem killing those sons of bitches but I do my best not to kill squirrels.

reply

I fucking hate rats. I can deal with the small ones. I'd just put rat poison on some food overnight & boom, I'd wake up to dead rats everywhere

It's the big ones I fucking hate. No matter what I did, they wouldn't go away. I tried the glue, the traps, poison & even called a few rat catchers, nothing worked.

They'd eat through the fucking wall. It was a cement wall!

I eventually just moved. God, I wish I could wipe them from the face of the earth.

reply

They can chew up the wiring in your car as well and that’s not cheap to fix. Disgusting pests, all of them!

I’m fortunate not to have a rat problem but I do believe I have a mouse behind the stove in the kitchen. It will die this week on a glue trap.

reply

I've had these 2 videos saved for the past few years

It's what nightmares are made of.

Video 1 from 1984: https://m.facebook.com/abcinsydney/videos/in-1984-this-farmer-used-a-flamethrower-to-deal-with-a-mouse-plague/228454592523718/

Video 2 from a Docu: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=zWVw-j8eYSk

reply

I can’t stand rats either. Years back I was doing an addition on my house and my eaves were open. Just as luck would have it we had a flood where the water came up to the house and rats came from the flooded woods. I could pop some of them with a .410 as they swam towards the house but some made it through. They crawled up the side of the house and into my attic where they made their way down the wall and inside. I went to war for about a week and and after many battles I ended up using the chemical warfare option. Lol

reply

Jeez, that sounds bad.
Boy, you get those scary floods down there!
I’m a Yankee, we mostly just complain about the snow.

I usually don’t use poison because I have a little dog and she’s a pesky goofball but sometimes you need to use it.

reply

Squirrels are nothing more than fuzzy tailed tree rats.

reply

But they're SO CUTE!

reply

This post is very relevant to me. I've only ever had one rat in my house. I finally caught the little bastard in a trap, and he was screaming like crazy, so I threw both trap and rat in a mop bucket and drowned him.

I'd say it's ethical to kill a rat because they invade the food supply and spread disease. However, a squirrel is not a filthy creature, they feed on nuts and live in the trees, so their existence in our backyards doesn't warrant death.

reply

I tend to agree.
Kill every disgusting rat, I feel NO remorse killing a rat or a mouse, they are disease bringers.

Glue traps are very effective on mice, just lay them where the floor meets the corner of your walls, the mice run right into this set-up, they are very stupid creatures.

I’ve used non-lethal traps on the squirrels up in the eaves and dumped them alive in the woods.
I’d prefer not to kill the squirrels.

However, if an annoying squirrel keeps invading the eaves and attic he’s asking for it . A good .177 air gun is quiet and effective, aim for the belly.
Get him in the belly and give him a second shot when he’s down or hit him with a handy stick.

I don’t much like killing squirrels but they sometimes break in and they can really mess up your roof and electricity.

reply

I've posted about killing the rat before. I got some angry responses saying I should have trapped it and let it go. I guess that's the new mindset.

I guess I forget about the mouse I killed in a glue trap. Glue traps are considered cruel and I can see why. It's a slow grueling death. I'd rather use a trap which kills them outright.

The squirrels here have never messed with the roofs. They stay in the trees.

reply

Ha! Trap the rat and release it to cause mischief elsewhere lol. People can be stupid…kill every rat you can, they are disease ridden and vile.

The glue trap is the way to go for the mice, it’s certainly cruel but I didn’t start the fight, I’m just going to win it.

reply

Yes, trapping and releasing a rat is like trapping and releasing cockroaches. They're vermin.

Personally, after seeing that poor struggling mouse in that glue trap overnight, I decided I can't use them. If I get another mouse I'll use the spring-loaded traps.

reply

Peanut Butter is a good bait on the trigger plate, the mice walk right up to it every time👍

reply

👍

reply

Lots of people don't know this but squirrels are rodents. They are just glorified rats with tails.

"I hate rats and have no problem killing those sons of bitches but I do my best not to kill squirrels."

I agree. When I moved 3 years ago I saw my neighbor had a trap set in his back yard. Asked him what he was trapping and he said squirrels. He said they are all over. Well I had two traps like you see below. I don't know how many squirrels he caught but I caught 67 of them. We would release them in the wood far from anyone's houses.

We now only see a squirrel once in awhile. If we get more the traps will come out again.

https://empire-s3-production.bobvila.com/articles/wp-content/uploads/2021/12/Best_Squirrel_Traps.png

reply

Wow, I’m in the Lower Hudson River Valley of New York State and we get some pesky squirrels but damn, you must live in a pine forest.
You have way more squirrels than I do!

I have a pair of those traps out in the barn, the ‘Havaheart’ type traps.
When I mowed lawns during my college years I charged $25 bucks to catch a squirrel in old people’s attics and chimneys lol.

Peanut Butter on White Bread tricks the Squirrels nearly every time.
The trigger plate in the Havaheart trap is Aluminum so it can seize up and not activate after the trap ages and rusts. Use Vaseline to loosen the action, bike oil and WD-40 are too stinky and they put the squirrels off. A proper trap should not be obvious.

I tended to put a bit of rubbish around the trap as well, make it sort of blend in for the squirrel to feel comfortable…old newspaper, logs, any junk you find around really.

Trap them and drive ‘em out to the woods and release them👌

reply

WOW $25 bucks to catch a squirrel. I could make a bundle of money in my neighborhood. ShogunofYonkers I ride my bikes on old country roads. One day I see this old farmer and we start talking. After awhile he asks me if I hunt. I say yes. He says his barn is being over run by squirrels. Tells me he will give me 5 dollars for each one I kill. He has no guns so I ride my bike home and load a few guns in my truck and go back. Ended up getting 13 of them. Made $65. Had to use my adult air rifle (below) because my shotgun and 22 rifle made to much noise.

https://images.proxibid.com/AuctionImages/4840/164056/FullSize/1258-1.jpg

reply

You did pretty well in that deal👍

reply

Yup on the hunt for a suspected rat . A squirrel was caught, maybe he was in on it, maybe wrong place wrong time. God rest his/her soul

reply

Why kill a rat, when you can trap it and release it by the house of someone you loathe?

reply

All rodents are vermin.

reply

Some humans are vermin as well.

reply

Your point being, what?Some members of some species are vermin, but all members of rodent species are vermin. You might try staying on the actual topic the next time instead of trying to highjack it for your own agenda.

reply

I raised guinea pigs when I was a kid. I love the little creatures. They are rodents. They are not vermin.

But interesting. Why are you so touchy about this topic? I wasn't accusing you. It was a general statement. Does this subject hit home to you?

reply

Marmots are also cute.

https://www.nps.gov/seki/planyourvisit/marmots.htm


From spring through mid-summer, the marmots of Mineral King have been known to dine on radiator hoses and car wiring.

How can you protect your vehicle and marmots?

-Wash the outside, undercarriage, and engine compartment of your vehicle before visiting.

-Physically block marmots by driving over a tarp and then wrapping it around your entire vehicle. Cover the wheel wells. Wrapping chicken wire around the vehicle is no longer advised, as marmots have learned to get around the wire.

- If you visit Mineral King, especially before August, check for possible damage when you return to your vehicle. Before starting your car, look under the hood for marmots or signs of chewing. Check hoses, belts, electrical wiring, insulation, and radiator fluid level. Inspect under the vehicle for signs of coolant or brake fluid leakage.
.
.
.
.
Is brake fluid important?

reply

I am racist (technically a specist ) when it comes to rodentia. I shoot rats and feed squirrels. So I'm going to go with squirrel.

reply

Update.

I thought it was a rat in my attic. I got a cam.
Its a big squirrel. And hes avoided my trap 2 times so far..

Soon he/she will make a mistake. And I'm gonna take it for swimming lessons

reply