MovieChat Forums > General Discussion > I don't understand why rock music isn't ...

I don't understand why rock music isn't more popular.


Rock is probably the most diverse genre of music. There's so many variations that someone could find of interest to them: hard rock, metal, punk, folk, psychedelic, alternative, goth, blues-rock, country-rock, soft, industrial, instrumental, progressive and more.

Almost all rock artists write everything they do. Most solo artists play an instrument. They don't use samples from other songs. They almost never have a guest artist appear on their albums to get "cred". How many times do we see something like, "Bitch, where's my money?" by Drake featuring: Jay-Z, Lil Wayne, Cardi B, Kanye West, Eminem and Ludacris?

The music itself uses the basic instrumental families: strings, percussion, woodwind, and brass. They rarely use instruments performed off of a "board". That loud "bass boom" we often hear in dance music sounds so manufactured.

I say, long live Rock 'n Roll!

reply

There was a thread a while back when someone asked if Rock is dead.
This was my answer:

Music styles and tastes change over the years. The way music is made and recorded changes over the years. And the quality of how we listen to music has also changed a lot. So, every generation gets something new and different.

The way each new generation is introduced to music has vastly changed over the past 20 years as well.
I'm 45, so any music I heard when I first heard popular music was whatever my parents were listening to on the radio or any LP that they had bought. I also think that because there was only radio in the car, I was exposed to mainstream music earlier than my kids who were forced to listen to kids' music CDs (not my choice).
Later, when I was in my teens and developed a taste if my own, my choice was still limited to either radio or LPs my friends' older brothers had.

If there was some music which I really did want to listen to whenever I wanted, I would have to go OUTSIDE and CATCH A BUS, and go to a MUSIC STORE and P A Y for what I wanted to hear. So I was very cautious about what music I bought. Today, you can hear anything with the click of a button, where ever you are, and whenever you want.

Music today is much easier and much cheaper to make. Home recording on computers over the last 20 years has given the opportunity for many to make music that could not do it before. But because it's so much easier to make music on a computer, fewer people are learning musical instruments like the Guitar and Drums.

These, in my opinion, have all had a huge negative impact on Rock simply because there are fewer people recording rock music. When I was in high school, there were three rock bands. In my son's school today (which is about the same size), there is only one.

reply


Music today is much easier and much cheaper to make. Home recording on computers over the last 20 years has given the opportunity for many to make music that could not do it before. But because it's so much easier to make music on a computer, fewer people are learning musical instruments like the Guitar and Drums.


I agree. But the thing is that now more than ever is it easier to discover something they've never heard before. I've discovered so many obscure bands because of YouTube. The biggest selling rock acts are the ones that have been around for years like AC/DC anThe Rolling Stones. Why it it so hard for rock artists to gain popularity?

reply

> But because it's so much easier to make music on a computer, fewer people are learning musical instruments like the Guitar and Drums.

It works the other way sometimes. In my college years I could do some wild things on the piano. By age thirty I couldn't do them anymore -- my fingers weren't quick enough anymore. With a computer I can still do those things even if I live to be ninety.

reply

My problem with today’s music is not so much how it’s made, but that it contains zero restraint. No subtleties, no nuance; it’s all in your face, 4/4 beats, and doesn’t pass our overlord’s gates unless it contains a message the we, personally, are the most super-duper important people that ever graced the universe. Me, me, me! I can’t figure out why we’re a bunch of navel gazers. 🤷🏻‍♂️

reply

I hate reading subtitles when I listen to my music.

reply

Autocorrect. Fixing. Thanks, erm, kind of, apart from the smugness. But, I understand, you’re really really important.

reply

You're no fun.

reply

It can be fun if you don’t know the lyrics. 😀

reply

Everything now just seems so simplistic. Just repeat the same line in the chorus (or "Started From the Bottom) and it's a hit.

reply

I appreciate music that innovates. Today’s music emulates.

reply

[deleted]

There's also no lasting power to most of the songs. How many of today's hits will you remember in 10, 20, 30 years?
Ever since I was a kid (I'm 45 now), I've listened to the charts. Next week we're going on a road trip and I made a playlist of the top 100 for the same week in 1985.
Here's the top 10:
1- Duran Duran - A View To A Kill
2- Prince And The Revolution - Raspberry Beret
3- Paul Young - Everytime You Go Away
4- Whitney Houston - You Give Good Love
5- Phil Collins - Sussudio
6- Survivor - The Search Is Over
7- Sting - If You Love Somebody Set Them Free
8- Bruce Springsteen - Glory Days
9- Tears For Fears - Shout
10- Eurythmics - Would I Lie To You?

Anyone of my generation would be able to sing the chorus to almost all of them without hearing them, even if they didn't like the song. The rest, you just need to play and they'll recognize them. Also worth mentioning, not one of these artists is a one-hit-wonder. They're all considered classics today.

Could you say the same about today's top 10? Will the kids today remember this in 35 years?
https://youtu.be/mxFstYSbBmc?t=80

reply

3 AND 8 ARE AWESOME...I WOULD JUMP OUT OF YOUR CAR AT THE REST OF THAT PLAYLIST...FOR STING,ID JUMP OUT WHILE IT WAS MOVING.

reply

If you look at the album charts in both the UK and US (and I assume that it's a similar story in Australia and Canadia [sic]), you'll see that Rock is alive and well.

reply

I don't think rock is dead, but I just don't feel that genres like rap and dance music should be more popular.

reply

I love all music, but 70s/80s rock is my favourite. The funny thing is, whenever I play this sort of stuff, straightaway all the young people start saying how much they prefer this to what's around today.

reply

I WOULD ADD 90S,BUT AGREE FOR THE MOST PART...EXCEPT...FOR THE LAST YEAR MY DAUGHTER AND I HAVE BEEN LISTENING TO SPOSE,AESOP ROCK,CAM GROVES,PINK THA PRODUCT,FLOBOTS,AND A FEW OTHERS...MODERN RAP/HIP HOP...I CANT BELIEVE IT MYSELF,BUT IM HOOKED...MIND YOU,THESE ARENT BIG NAME ARTISTS...HEADLINING MAJOR TOURS AND WHORING THEMSELVES ON EVERY ALBUM WITH 33 GUEST STARS....WITH SO MUCH CONTENT THESE DAYS,ONLY THE MAJOR NAMES GET ANY REAL PROMOTION...LEAVING THE FAN TO DO THE WORK OF DISCOVERING THE GOOD STUFF...WHICH IS LIKE DIGGING THROUGH A DUMPSTER LOOKING FOR NICKELS.

reply

Long live, indeed....for some, it’s been a long time...

https://youtu.be/IbW5K2F1N28

Just lots of variety and different tastes nowadays....it’s cool, some are still following the tradition, enough to where those who only want their rock fix can get some....Foo Fighters, Greta van fleet (We know the Zep comparisons, sound-wise), Muse, S.O.D, Three Days Grace, Radiohead, Green Day, Kings of Leon, Rise Against, Queens of the Stone Age, and a few other bands still bring it if you like it....

Good times!

reply

Just give me a cool guitar riff and I'm happy.

reply

i heard the term yacht rock a few days ago for the first time.

reply

I think this is the official submission for that genre....

https://youtu.be/VzgQoGvSKA4

reply

i wasn't aware of the term. it's just another name for soft rock.

reply

I typed it in on YouTube. No thanks to that kind of rock.

reply

I love yacht rock!

reply

On your yacht, Andy the King?

reply

I decided against buying one; a friend of mine has a boat, so I know what a money pit they can be.

reply

Funny, that’s what some of my friends say, just cut a hole in your pocket, you’d save more that way than to buy a boat....

reply

Honesty, if I want to go out on a boat I’ll hire one. I don’t go out enough to warrant buying one, plus the mooring fees, maintenance etc.

reply

my friends say "Sailing in Scotland is akin to standing under a cold shower tearing up £10 notes"
:)

reply

Haha...

reply

THE TWO HAPPIEST DAYS IN A BOAT OWNER'S LIFE....THE DAY HE BUYS THE BOAT...AND THE DAY HE SELLS IT.

reply

I’m sinking money into one now with fiberglass work.

reply

HAD A BOAT WHEN I WAS A KID...IT WAS A LOT OF FUN...I WISH YOU LUCK WITH YOUR NAUTICAL INVESTMENT.🙂

reply

I have more than one but they are common here. I think most everyone’s yard has one in it even though some turn into lawn ornaments. Lol but thank you for the good wishes.

reply

The problem with rock music is just that they're TOO long lasting. People still listen to GnR, Rolling Stones, Queen, etc.

Now try listening too old rap music, like Kriss Kross or MC Hammer... they sound SO OLD! Nobody would want to be caught dead listening to those ever again today.

And that's the problem with rock music. People keep listening the old ones and not buying the new ones. With pop and rap, people constantly wanting the newest songs. So more new music, more money.

Also, when the old legends won't die, how can a new no name musicians thrive? With pop and rap, legends become old and irrelevant, people tend to seek new artists. With rock, a new no name band would always compete againts those classic songs from legendary bands. Can you imagine competing againts Metallica or Def Leppard? It's just a f@#$% uphill battle!

reply

Interesting point, A-man...but I will say I like my rap with a message, whether it be political or social issue-oriented....so Public Enemy and N.W.A, I’ll take anytime....and now, that’s why I like Immortal Technique....it’s almost criminal that he isn’t more well known, but the people in the know, they know what’s up....

https://youtu.be/v5LUsqzn1JM

But you have a point....for me, it is hard to compete with the Stones, Zep, Hendrix and other greats from the past....hell, it’s hard to compete with Massive Attack, which has elements of rock and a bunch of other genres....

https://youtu.be/61jfm219ArA

Good times!



reply

Same here. Eric B and Rakim - Paid in Full is still one of my favorite albums.

reply

The whole musical concept has been perverted over the years thanks to the likes of Aerosmith, Slayer and Slipknot just to name a few. It's such a perplexing deviation from what music in it's grassroots form was like, that I don't consider it music.

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]

If there is a band picture on someone's T-shirt, it's a band not worth listening to.

Edit: I don't know why that sent 4 times.

reply

You can find pretty much any band on a t shirt.

reply

I agree. Even obscure ones.

reply

I love me the people who wear band t shirts when they have never even heard the band, they just think the art work is cool or they like the attitude they think wearing the band t shirt gives them.

reply

I never understood people who wear shirts without knowing anything about the band. You're opening yourself up to insults if the band is awful.

reply

Quite often it is obvious the person isn't a fan/hasn't heard of the band too. I work with a guy who walked in wearing a Ramones T Shirt, I was a bit surprised but held back on judgement. I started a chat about the band with him and he told me he just wears what his girlfriend buys him. ROFLMAO.

reply

just show us on the doll where Aerosmith touched you....

Slayer and Slipknot , yeah i'm with you . Korn too.

reply

Everything today is just crappy pop. All the songs sound boring with forgettable beats and melodies.

I love me some classic rock music. I'm listening to Deep Purples album "Machine Head" right now.

reply

My favourite Deep Purple album. I'm listening to Black Sabbath right now.

reply

I love Black Sabbath. Paranoid is my favourite album.

reply