MovieChat Forums > General Discussion > When vegetarians try to argue that we ar...

When vegetarians try to argue that we aren’t supposed to eat meat


Cooking and eating meat actually contributed significantly to the evolution of our brains in prehistory. That’s why I laugh at vegetarians pushing their agenda. That’s fine if you don’t want to eat meat but don’t ever tell me humans/primates aren’t “supposed” to eat meat.

reply

More for me 😁

reply

Yup! 🍔🌭🍗🥩

reply

i haven't taken the pledge myself, but find the argument from sustainability compelling.

the fact that meat-eating spurred human evolution isn't, in itself, an argument for its necessity in the present.

reply

I think it is. Everything about our biological health is tied into our evolution, which is why it is very difficult to get our required protein from anything but an animal or animal products.

reply

there are probably a billion or so vegetarians on the planet. it's a well trodden path in life.

your argument doesn't really hold up in practice. you and i may enjoy meat, but that doesn't mean one can't be healthy living a vegetarian lifestyle.

reply

Yes Indians look so healthy 🤣

That may of course be mostly due to poverty but I see lots of sickly looking vegans round these parts as well.

reply

"the fact that meat-eating spurred human evolution isn't, in itself, an argument for its necessity in the present."

Evolution, by definition, is not a terminal process. I'm sure we haven't finished yet.

reply

certainly true. humanity is, for much of the current biota, an agent of mass extinction. which will, in turn, effect our own evolution.

reply

Haha, yes, our extinction would certainly affect our evolution! But I doubt that's going to happen.

reply

It's an odd argument to be saying that everyone should go vegetarian when the planet is basically a giant meat eating slaughterhouse.

reply

Yeah lol

reply

As the population grows our ability to sustainably grow meat for slaughter will be significantly impacted until it simply is no longer feasible.
That time is not yet here.
Thank the flavor gods.

reply

haha thanks the flavour gods.

reply

Most vegetarians also follow the need for population control.I would go with the meat available given to the ones that have a religion that says they follow that. Others can live off insects that will some be allowed to be consumed.
https://www.cnn.com/2019/10/25/health/insects-feed-save-planet-wellness/index.html

reply

Uh, ok.

reply

Well I know Habib and he will share what is able to be raised of the polluting cattle with the rest of us in the future.

reply

I've got some friends who are veggies and they are certainly not all in my face about it. I keep hearing about these militant vegetarians and vegans but I'm yet to meet one. Personally, I enjoy vegetarian food and could probably handle it if it becomes the norm for sustainability or whatever.

For now though, pass me that steak.

reply

You know how you can tell when there's a vegan at the party?
They will tell you!

reply

I'll have to take your word for that!

Just quietly though, one thing I STRONGLY disagree with is animal activists who trespass on private farming property to protest, steal livestock, block roads and generally cause chaos for these farmers. I'm a big believer in ethical treatment of farm animals but disrupting the lives of people who are providing an essential service is just bad form and counterproductive.

reply

Stats show that the most active nature conservationists are hunters followed closely by farmers.
Not activists.

reply

I can see the logic, but I don't like when that argument is rolled out to support trophy hunting of exotic and/or endangered animals. When I see a photo of a fat American in Africa posing proudly with his foot on the head of a dead elephant, I don't buy that he did it to save the environment.

When my dad was alive he was a keen hunter but always went out to rural properties on the permission of the landowners to shoot pests like rabbits and wild boar; so I'm certainly not against sport hunting if it's done responsibly.

reply

Everyone who eats meat should at least once go out and hunt, clean, cook and eat their own game. It’s rewarding to say the least.

reply

I'm pretty sure half the world would starve if they couldn't get their food neatly packaged.

reply

That’s what zip locks are made for. 😄

reply

“When I see a photo of a fat American in Africa posing proudly with his foot on the head of a dead elephant, I don't buy that he did it to save the environment.“

🤣 Yeah I get a chuckle out of that too, idiots.

reply

One thing to be aware of is what you see, is not always the whole story. There was a post showing a pretty girl next to a large giraffe that she killed and OH! The outrage!! What the didn't tell us was that giraffe was an aged, aggressive male past it's mating prime and he was killing smaller, upcoming males. If left unchecked, he would have lead to the destruction of the herd so they sanctioned her to kill it. Then they fed the whole village with it. A lot of these "sensational" post are showing similar situations where the animal needs to be put down.

reply

Stats show that the most active nature conservationists are hunters followed closely by farmers.

what stats? How do you measure an "Active nature conservationist" ?
Arnt we all doing that when we put our recycling into the correct bins?

reply

It's measured by financial contributions and actual physical contributions. WTF do you think?!
You should know at least a LITTLE about the subject you're discussing.
Being raised in a family of hunters AND farmers, I actually DO know just a teeny tiny little something. Not to mention LIVING in that same environment.

reply

If you hunt or fish the last thing you want go there to be less fish and game. That’s why most hunters and fishermen go to great lengths to conserve and enhance the environment to make it a better ecosystem. Hunters and fishermen are part of the balance of environmental ecosystems. It’s just like tree farmers. There are more trees in the United States right now than there were in 1901 because tree farmers plant trees. In the early 1900’s duck populations were being wiped out by hunters feeding the demand in France. Now migratory birds and their habitats are Managed. That’s why there are seasons and limits. Coastal erosion is a real threat in some gulf areas and hunters and fishermen back that cause as another example. Hunting and fishing permits, boat registrations WMA fees and many other thing’s have portions of the proceeds going directly into conservation. Just to Duck Hunt in Louisiana one must purchase a Federal and State Duck stamp that combined amounts to around 30 dollars and I think that goes to wetland conservation also.

As far as recycling, most hunters and fishermen I know try to recycle and never litter. We want our fields and waterways clean to produce a thriving habitat for generations to come.

reply

Thank you for putting a much better voice to that question. I get upset when the inexperienced say things that they haven't even bother to Google.

reply

My pleasure. It’s always been amazing to me how some uninformed people think hunters and fishermen are problems, when in most cases, they do more for our environment than most other segments of the population.

reply

My paternal grandfather hunted his entire life as a matter of necessity. No hunt equaled no meat for 13 kids and 2 adults.
Mistreatment of his forest endangered his family!
I watched him threaten to kill a man who had shot a yearling (a yearling!) just to cut out the backstrap and dump the rest in a ditch. Sorry piece of shit.

reply

Some people have no morals.

reply

I don't get the vegans. Dairy and eggs aren't killing anything and it opens up so many food options by just adding those two things.

reply

Everyone has their own beliefs and as long as it's feasible and doesn't hurt anyone that's fine. My parents were "upper middle class" in the military so life was fairly comfortable, but they never forgot their early hardships and did their best to teach us those hard lessons. One was to take what is offered.
Plus if you've ever been truly hungry, ALL your preconceptions about food will Very quickly disappear.
I suspect that the vast majority of vegans haven't missed many meals.

reply

Most farm animals are kept in horrible conditions. They're basically tortured their whole lives. I'm not a vegan, but I can understand why they would be turned off to being a part of a cruel system. People pretend that animals aren't consciously aware nor have emotions, but they do.

reply

i like eating vegetarian and i like eating meat, i like to eat vegan a lot. meat is fine I just think we need to be aware of the environment - humans have always killed animals for meat to eat but you don't have to have it if your not out hunting and gathering

reply

I like food in general. If it's palatable I'm happy to stuff it in my gullet 😁
One of the best meals I've had, around the nicest people, was a Thanksgiving I spent at a Krishna house.

reply

thats Beautiful

reply

It was an eye opening experience, an epiphany. It altered my perceptions and changed my outlook on people and ideas.

reply


I either ignore them, or laugh in their faces. Full disclosure: I'm a member of PETA: People Eating Tasty Animals.

😎

reply

*palms forehead.
some people will never change... haha
okay so eating animals is fine but you don't have to everyday.

reply


No, I don't have to, but I WANT to!

😎

reply

Fair enough! I'm sure theres enough land for all the cows. I sometimes worry about that but try not to. I think it might be an issue in deforestation. what if they didn't have enough land and so meat prices where really high - would you eat a meat from a cloned animal grown in a lab? i wouldn't i'd rather be veg.

reply


Fortunately I will never have to make that choice.

😎

reply

that's probably true.

reply

I’m a carnivore with canine teeth.

reply