MovieChat Forums > General Discussion > Does anybody else get bothered when a mo...

Does anybody else get bothered when a movie is set in a certain place...


...but looks absolutely nothing like the real-life location?

Like most movies set in Texas are almost always filmed in the desert, even though less than 10% of Texas is geographically considered to be of desert climate? The X-Files Movie is the most egregious offender in this example, where Dallas is shown to be in an arid sandy desert. I guess nobody on the set of that $80 million production could look up that Dallas is actually located in a green, hilly region nowhere near a desert? Same with The Texas Chainsaw Massacre 3, which shows a massive cactus-filled desert just "three hours from Houston". Houston is located between the Gulf Of Mexico, green farmland, and the dense piney woods. The original TCM was filmed in Texas and is NOT in the desert.

Any other geography nerds get peeved by stuff like this? It happens pretty often.

reply

Yes like when they filmed ' On the Beach ' a film about the end of the world and set it in Melbourne. How dare they !

reply

My favorite along those lines was an old movie, circa 1950, about the Civil War in Kansas. It was shot in California's Sierra Nevada mountains, for some reason!

Yeah, Kansas is full of steep wooded slopes, pine woods, mountain peaks, and the characteristic pale gray bornhard boulders you see in the Sierras, right?

reply

I hear ya about Texas. Movies getting it wrong even becomes "gospel" to people in other countries. I told a UK friend a story about one of my Texas experiences, then someone who came into the room late asked, and my friend retold what I'd said and added "in the desert" -- as her own embellishment. Even though my story took place in lush, hilly central TX hundreds of miles from the desert!

Drives me nuts.

Movies also make London, England, look nothing like it really is too, and people in other countries take it as fact.

reply

Friday the 13th part 8, they try to pass off some Canadian city like Vancouver as NY. Pretty funny.

reply

A lot of movies pass off Canadian cities as NYC. Most of the time it's too expensive to film in New York. Law and Order SVU actually films in New Jersey except for location shoots.

reply

Generally not unless there’s some politically/socioeconomically damaging/exploitive reason why. A film is a construction, and verisimilitude and realism are way at the bottom of my priorities. And I’m usually too dumb to notice.

reply

I just remembered that The Revenant is set in North Dakota but is shown as very mountainous. The real North Dakota is so flat you could iron your clothes on it.

Same thing with Logan, which shows North Dakota as mountainous.

reply

Yea... it bothered me a little when the movie said it was in The Netherlands while it's obviously Holland.

reply

30 Days of Night is based in Barrow Alaska which looks nothing like the quaint little town in the movie. It's a major hub. Also it is located nowhere near the pipeline. Strangely enough though it worked for the purposes of the film.

reply

You can also add on the fact that the real Barrow is almost fifty percent Inuit. The mixture of people in the film: white, Asian and Aboriginal only exists in Australia where the movie was filmed.

reply

Was the film really shot in Australia? That's crazy.

reply