MovieChat Forums > General Discussion > Do We Really Need Commentary During Spor...

Do We Really Need Commentary During Sporting Events?


People actually attending the event get along just fine without any commentary. Why? BECAUSE THEY CAN SEE WHAT THE HELL IS GOING ON! How does hearing, “Oh! He’s just been tackled!” enhance one’s viewing experience? And then there’s the utterly meaningless alleged statistic, which is really not a statistic at all, but is a mere datum that correlates with noting at all. “Yes, Ted, Smith was tackled, good call! Did you know that, in 6 percent of games played in December on the East Coast, teams who had a guy named Smith who got tackled went on to win by an average of 1.06 points?! It’s LOOKIN’ GOOD for the Home Team!”

reply

Going to a sporting event is a social event - sitting in front of the TV is not and IMO falls into the entertainment category more so than actually being at a game. We have become conditioned to announcers. One time I was on a cruise that had a football game on but the announcers had been blanked out because it was broadcasted through Telemundo. It was just plain weird to watch the game in silence.

reply

So what? If you had been in the stadium, what would you have missed? The commentators are useless clods.

reply

The only sport I really follow is football and unless it's a game I'm particularly interested in watching from start to finish, I don't sit glued to the TV on Sundays for all three games, so it's nice to do stuff around the house and listen to the games and if something really exciting happens, then I can stop and watch.

Honestly,(besides the obvious), why is TV with announcers any different than play calling on the radio?

reply


Many years back they tried broadcasting an NFL game with no commentators. It bombed big time.

😎

reply

It does seem to ad an extra dimension to it. Couldn't tell you why.

reply

Because they do not add anything. If you know and savor the sport, you know how superfluous the commentary is. If you don’t, why are you watching a sport of which you are so ignorant? Placed a bet, maybe?

reply

AS A LIFELONG LAKER FAN....CHICK HEARN,NUFF SAID.

reply

I think some of it is because it's TV the viewer may only be seeing certain sections of the ground/play at any one point. I don't know, I miss it when the camera guys were allowed to film the hot chicks in the audience. Not being a sports fan I found that more interesting.

reply

For the most part I don't mind the commentary as long as it remains pertinent to the action. Sometimes a little background information or statistics can augment the experience.

What I object to is constant barrage of advertising. Not just the commercial breaks, which are bad enough as it is, but the unending name-dropping of the sponsors throughout the broadcast. In football there's the [sponsor's name] Pre-game Show, the [sponsor's name] Halftime Report and the [sponsor's name] Post-game Show. When stats include an on-screen graphic there's a sponsor's logo attached to it. Logos are scattered all throughout the venue, and even the stadiums themselves are named after some corporation.

In hockey the boards around the ice are covered with a chain of logos. I've seen some games where additional logos are projected electronically onto the glass above the boards, using a technology where it is seen only by viewers at home, but not by the fans in attendance. In basketball they now insert quick five-second blurbs between shots during free throws! This is going too far. The games are becoming secondary to the advertising, a prime example being the Super Bowl. There are people who watch the Super Bowl for the idiotic commercials!

This continues to escalate and has increased in frequency just within the past couple of years. I am on the verge of shutting off the NFL and sticking with college football.

reply

Do we even need to see them at all?

reply

Not really. Slightly off topic but a big beef of mine is that the script Ohio is hardly ever shown before Ohio State football games. I went to OSU and it's such a big part of the pre game excitement but they always cut it off with either commercials or some stupid commentary.

reply

Just put the commentators on your ignore list.

reply

Good one 🤣

reply

Thread winner! 🤣🤣🤣

reply