MovieChat Forums > Politics > So, why don't you support Black Lives Ma...

So, why don't you support Black Lives Matter?


Curious to see the reasons why people here don't support Black Lives Matters when all the movement is doing is standing up against injustice and racism and has the goal of dismantling the systems that enable them.

reply

The haters have been exposed to hard anti BLM propaganda by Rush Limb., Infowars and Fox News talking heads. The people that say in response to BLM that all lives matter are often the people who won't wear mask thus not caring about all lives.

reply

Indeed

reply

You’ve also have bought their Marxists lies hook, line, and sinker! Watch the links I posted to the OP.

reply

Here's a link. All the things pubs hold dear -- big medical bills, retired vets (in this case, police officers) living in poverty, no social safety net, lax gun laws. The world pubs want us to live in.

https://getpocket.com/explore/item/arming-the-cartels-the-inside-story-of-a-texas-gun-smuggling-ring?utm_source=pocket-newtab

And you have the gall to raise the red herring flag of Marxism? This country has Capitalism shoved so far up it's ass that 100 years of change wouldn't bring about Marxism. But rather than confront how biased toward industry and unforgiving to the poor the pub platform is, just bray nonsense about Marxism like the idiots who brayed about Pizzagate. Watch the gun nuts run around shooting at the "Marxists,." while the rest of us moderate and sober thinking wonder why we haven't all learned from The War Of The Worlds hoax. Chicken Little disguised as political rhetoric.

reply

You're wrong.

BLM is a terrorist organization because they fit the textbook/dictionary definition absolutely perfectly. They nailed it perfectly. Funny part is that terrorist money is funneled to the DNC for the 2020 election cycle.

Good Times, America. Good Times.

So whether I hate them or love them or don't give one little flying fuck is not relevant, they are a terrorist organization. Period.

Now go scream your lungs out at me.

reply

I don't see the NBA openly endorsing a terrorist group. Every game there's a majority of players wearing BLM attire and it's very clear to see. No suspensions. No orders to stop representing BLM.

reply

Are you serious? If so, you have bought their lies hook, line and sinker! BLM is a Marxist domestic terrorist group of thugs!

Black Lives Matter co-founder describes herself as ‘trained Marxist’

https://nypost.com/2020/06/25/blm-co-founder-describes-herself-as-trained-marxist/

If you care to watch:

Gun-Wielding Protesters Point Weapons At Motorists, Indianapolis Leaders Stay Silent

http://www.tonykatz.com/2020/08/07/gun-wielding-protesters-stop-motorists-in-indianapolis/

reply

So what if they are Marxist? Some of you say this thinking it amounts to an argument.

reply

”So what if they are Marxist?

It’s going to take someone with more knowledge than me to articulate the dangers of Marxism/Communism. I located some info. God help us if people like you become in complete control of our country, a Republic!

And yet, very few in the West have truly come to grips with what has happened in history when Marxists get their way. We all know about the horrors of Nazi Germany but the slaughter of 100 million people by communist regimes of the twentieth century seems not to have registered. 3 Specifically, historians now estimate, only as a starting point, 61 million deaths in the Soviet Union, 38.6 million in China, two million in Cambodia (then called the Khmer Rouge), 1.6 million in North Korea, and 1.2 million in Yugoslavia. 4 We know lots about Hitler — who his girlfriend was, what kind of music he listened to — but virtually nothing about Lenin, Stalin, Mao, or Pol Pot, or the others in Communism’s panoply.

reply

So what if they are Marxist????

What that means is their agenda has nothing to with black lives but changing the status quo to Marxist leanings - in other words disabling capitalism which has caused the U.S. and may other countries to thrive, and instead change to one that has proven time and time again to simply not work.

It sounds like you don't understand what Marxism is since you shrugged at it so easily.
Marxism is a belief that that society should have no classes. It might seem great in theory to the naive, but it doesn't work. Power corrupts. Those in power will still be a different, better class. You think Stalin lived in a hut and sowed the fields? Or any of his generals? Or some of those running companies in a Marxist society? No, what Marxism does is crush the middle class, give the 10% even more power, and the rest of society waits in line for bread and is forced into jobs they don't want. You want to be a doctor? Nope - go work on an assembly line. You want to own your own house? Nope - there is no private ownership. If you have any money it's not yours anymore but the collective. Then the government has all the control and you'll see them force their will on you and there is nothing you can do about it.

Go look at videos of the Berlin wall falling down and see how many East Berliners were trampling over each other to get to the other side.

reply

Thank you much for helping me explain to the ignorant masses, those who ask ”So what if they are Marxist?”, the dangers of Marxism.

reply

You are confusing economic Marxism with cultural/racial Marxism.

Marxists fight for communism, which is equality. But these Marxists are not calling for economic communism. They specifically describe themselves as cultural Marxists because they want all people of all colors to be treated equally by the law.

The disagreement between the right and left is not on whether racial equality should exist. The right's perception is that racial communism has already been obtained. And the left's perception is that work still needs to be done. And so anyone who is working to achieve it is rightfully called a Marxist.

In fact, the ONLY instance where Marxism is bad is personal wealth. One should not FIGHT to take something that does not belong to them. However, the vast majority of us agree that fighting for equal rights is not fighting for something that doesn't belong to you. It's fighting for something you should already have, but for whatever reason, you don't.

reply

Define it however you want - you can call it a potato or you can call it a potatoe. Both make french fries. There are a ton of factions and big words you can toss around with different definitions, like progressive democrat and Marxist democrat and social democracy. Like those, egalitarianism is the dream and Marxism is the reality of that dream. (I assume there is a reason they are calling themselves Marxists and not Egalitarians?)

Who is this vast majority? Are you referring to BLM supporters? I guarantee 90% of BLM protestors have no idea they are working for Marxists.

Look, I am all for people protesting if they know what they are protesting for. Some are protesting cop violence, some are protesting the establishment, and some are protesting just to rape, pillage, and cause chaos. What's the end game for this? It depends on which protester you ask. That's a massive, massive problem and spirals down to nothing.

reply

I am not just defining it though. I am explaining everything they stand for and how it applies to Marxism. Marxists are people who fight for equality. You can define it as egalitarianism, but Marxism has an extra connotation of someone who is actively fighting.

If you agree with what they believe in, but do not accept that they fight for it, then fine. But we both know that's not going to get you very far in a debate that all Marxism is inherently wrong.

reply

Fair enough. Feel free to believe what you want - you won't sway my opinion on the matter either.

Again though, who are 'they' of which you speak of?

reply

They are those who define themselves as cultural Marxists.

And this is a prime example of why its silly to get hung up on labels.

Instead focus on what they say they want to achieve. Because chances are any label can apply to anything.

Labels are a right-wing shortcut to controlling the conversation, so I understand why it's done. People are just dumb. We even hear Trumpers say 'ZOMG Socialism!' with regard to Biden. It's pure silliness out there.

reply

Isn't what you just wrote extremely hypocritical? You just used labels saying it's what 'right-wingers' and 'Trumpers' do. If those two terms aren't labels than what is?

I don't think it's silly to label a movement because every movement has to have a theme. Both sides do it equally - in fact I'd say liberals go overboard labeling their different groups so much I can't keep up with the acronyms.

Ignore that - so what do, for lack of a better word, 'cultural Marxists', or 'they' as you want to call them, hope to achieve? What is the end goal? If you're not a Marxist then the name 'Marxist' shouldn't be your name, right? I'm a cow so I'm not going to call myself a chicken.

Going a step further, what does cultural Marxism have to do with Black Lives Matter, which is supposed to be a movement about police brutality? My initial thought is it's using a sensitive topic like racism to hide an agenda and deception to mask a larger movement.

Everything I wrote above has to do with the question "why don't you support Black Lives Matter." I support organized efforts for change. I support protesting peacefully. If I don't like what is going on I can vote against it. You can vote against it. I don't support torching towns, ripping up statues you decide you don't like, and taking over entire city blocks for some occupation protest and self-declared autonomous zone that ended up causing serious damage, arson, murder, rape, and endangers people's lives.




reply

tonykatz ... need anyone say anything more?

reply

Lmao!!!

Black Lives Matter Inc is a front to raise money for the Democrat party. This is old news. The organization is made up of angry wealthy white liberals, mostly female.

Black lives matter the movement, is racist. Hence the name. Theres no reason to support a racist terrorist group. They are not persuasive, they do inspire. They do not peacefully protest. Their goal is the disruption of peaceful society.

Just another whiney left wing group of protestors who accomplish nothing.

reply

Exactly, Gd.
I keep forgetting how they raise money for the Dems. Thanks for the reminder!

reply

i wish i had affirmative action. i wish i had free cellphones from obuma. i wish i had internet reduced to only 10 bucks a month for low income welfare leeches while i pay 40 bucks to att for the same shitty service. there is racism towards whites and asians these days when it comes to getting into schools. black people love to cry and complain but they are benefiting way more from the system than whites. hope to move away to Poland soon when i get old so i dont have to get some affirmative action surgeon slicing me up when i get sick and old

reply

Because Donald Trump is going to be reelected causing hundreds of thousands of black people to go out and shoot each other while he is in office.

reply

Sorry, I don't answer loaded questions. But since you're fond of them, here's one for you.

Have you stopped beating your wife?

reply

Because I’m a vile racist, obviously.

reply

https://youtu.be/v2ybGalXOX4?t=149

Here's one reason why someone wouldn't support BLM.

reply