MovieChat Forums > Harry Potter > Who would you save?

Who would you save?


If you could choose one character not to die, regardless of plot, who would you save?

I would save Sirius Black. I loved his character so much and felt so bad for Harry losing him.




"Destiny is a fickle b!tch"

reply

Sirius was always a doomed character, IMO. I'd save either Dobby or Hedwig.

Make a move, Reindeer Games..

reply

I would save Fred.

reply

Dobby

Look like Tarzan talk like Jane! HAHA

reply

fred, because he was so young, and got such fun out of life, and because it must have been devestating for his family.

reply

Severus Snape

I will never let you part, for you are always in my heart: MJ
turn to page 394: Snape

reply

Yeah, Fred was a hard one to lose but he was of age and a full fledged member of The Order, so I think that at least gives his death the elevated status of dying a hero.
My second choice would be Cedric for exactly your reasons for Fred.
he was so young, and got such fun out of life, and because it must have been devestating for his family.
How heart wrenching it was to hear Amos Diggory cry over his son.





"Destiny is a fickle b!tch"

reply

Lupin, or Tonks. Fred's death was heart-breaking too, but he did at least not have a new-born son. 

Intelligence and purity.

reply

Pandora Lovegood, her death was an accident and Luna is too sweet to be left alone. At least she'd have her family growing up. Although I'd deprive her of her ability to see Nargles.

I'd do the same thing for Harry and George... I'd bring back Fred and Sirius for the same reason....

Praise from the praise-worthy is beyond all rewards.
http://ow.ly/buqc302drQZ

reply