MovieChat Forums > Asian Cinema > Shin Godzilla [update; review]

Shin Godzilla [update; review]


I am totally not into Godzilla movies. But I watched this trailer like four times and it puts a smile on my face. If the film is directed half as well as the trailer, this is going to be awesome. Only showing for one week (!) in major U.S. cities, so imperative to catch it in the theater. Apparently it's a huge hit in Japan and getting pretty good reviews. Really gifted directors all understand the importance of music, huh?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zgyq6YKeIms

reply

My only concern is whether or not this director can maintain interest between the action scenes. I do not want a lot of dull conference room talks in this, but that seems to be the case based on some reviews I've read.

YouTube Asian Movie Review Channel
https://www.youtube.com/user/anticlimacus100

reply

I hear ya. I have kind of the opposite concern, because I'm not really into straight action flicks, and the write up in the WaPo made it out to have a lot of political subtext to the bureaucracy scenes... we'll see. The trailer is super stylish tho'.

reply

I don't get it. Movie trailers, that is. What was that? 30 seconds of fast cuts of people making intense faces.

\_-|/`— ... my opinions are incomplete. always wil

reply

Sorry, I don't like being a buzzkill.

I did, inexplicably, watch a trailer recently that I thought was a wonderful piece of art. I'm going to watch the film and dislike it when it comes out because the director has become an icky hack, but I like this trailer:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=whldChqCsYk

Correct me if I'm wrong, but it's pretty cool, yes? The sound design makes it so.

reply

Ha! Awesome trailer indeed. There is a real trend, suddenly, this year of doing trailers with just a song and none of the dialog at all. I'm loving it, every one (The Accountant, I Am Not Madame Bovary, Godzilla, this one) I have have seen so far has been awesome. Not tired of this yet at all.

reply

Good times!

I was surprised that they added a show at a suburban NY multiplex and the place was almost filled to the max. Got a round of applause at the end.

This flick was surprisingly, subtly weird and different from established things you do in the way a movie is made. It was a basic action movie, but really just like an anime in live action. The style of of directing and editing is straight out of anime: whip fast and snappy, with the wide-angle close-ups of faces, machine-gun rat-a-tat speech and expressionless faces and cartoonish reactions, wry deadpan lines. The director has a super distinct style and he clearly knew exactly what he wanted. I have to commend any director that does something different. I can't exactly call it original, but it's almost jarringly different, including the score, and I will pay ten bucks for that any day and twice on Sunday. Some bits from the original 1950s score were used to fantastic effect.

Hiroki Hasegawa (Mr. Overactor-face from Love & Peace) was just great in the lead. Hottie Satomi Ishihara, not so much, bless her heart, she was in over her head with the English. It's not so much as cast as a collection of pencil drawings.

There were a lot of flaws and weaknesses here, but I'm not inclined to pick at them. Way too many title cards and with the fast speech, the subtitle-reading is once again overwhelming. They should have spared a thought for international audiences when they planned to release it in 106 territories.

Overall, it's proportionally just as 'bad' as the original Godzilla movies were bad. But the director is not overshooting the originals and trying to do better -- he's trying to do "just as fun" with the intentional flat, one-dimensional characters crossed with a deeply wry and observant take on the bureaucratic reality of a monster invasion. Ironically, it only bogs down in the scenes with Godzilla and cgi, because that's when it starts to feel like any other action movie. But the pace is so damn snappy that these only last for seconds.

Not a great movie but worth $10 in the theater for the feeling of occasion. Eight point two for fun.

reply

I just saw this a few hours ago. I agree with your overall assessment and will post my review on Sunday.

YouTube Asian Movie Review Channel
https://www.youtube.com/user/anticlimacus100

reply