Feeling guilty for not liking it more
I'm supposed to like it because this is Noah Baumbach's girlfriend and I feel I should like it more than I do. The Beth sequences are really unmoving because Greta Gerwig doesn't believe in being "mawkish" (Larry David's criticism of Little Women on Curb Your Enthusiasm), so she presents Beth's bout with scarlet fever and eventual death out of chronological order so it isn't played for the tears it usually is, but presenting it in this way makes us utterly cold to her character so that we don't care when she dies. I can't even remember the actress's name. Timothee Chalomet is a very irritating Laurie and enacts the role as if on speed (witness his terrible dancing at the post-Christmas ball). I felt a little bad for Bob Odenkirk whom I always like because he was given nothing to do. Saorise---not tomboyish enough, not spirited as in the book, but a passable performance.
share