MovieChat Forums > Joe Versus the Volcano (1990) Discussion > Film's esoteric meaning, that only a few...

Film's esoteric meaning, that only a few truly understand



Joe versus the Volcano is one of the most important films in history, but had little impact on both the critics viewpoint and box office success. The importance of this movie is in its title, message, symbolism, and metaphor to explore numerous complex themes.

Through the main character's journey, the concepts of class, social status, good and evil, love and the existence of god are all examined as Joe Banks speculates upon his personal beliefs and his place in the universe.

The movie evolves around Joe's disturbing life, despicable co-workers, low paying dead-end job and the hopelessness of his future. But, everything begins to change for Joe after being told he had a terminal condition, a "brain-cloud" and had only 6 months to live. As Joe became more conscious of his own mortality and personal misery, he quickly set out to change it.

He began to discover that his life was a precious gift, whether he realized it or not. That in order to obtain happiness and joy in this world, we sometimes have to lose our life in order to find it. That's what happen to Joe. And his first order of business was to quit his job and start a new life.

While cleaning out his desk, he pulls out three book that symbolizes the essence of life, Robinson Crusoe (representing self-discovery), Romeo and Juliet (representing true love) and Homer's Odyssey (representing god and heroes). Books that he had, but did not use. They were laying dormant in his drawer, but now the student was ready to be taught.

John Patrick Shanley's genius was to show us, as Patricia stated on the boat, that we'll all asleep, in trance, reliving our past experiences and therefore forfeiting the present moment. That our need is "stay awake" by letting go of the past and to live our lives without being fearful of our future. To take risks, which is why Joe took the "Leap of Faith" literally in the Volcano, the Volcano metaphorically representing fear. Joe versus his fears.

This movie wasn't about Joe's sacrifice on the island or the Waponi's precious minerals, it was about awakening to our higher spiritual nature. This story so clearly demonstrated through Joe, how our rigid, conditioned thinking, keeps us chained to the past and fearful of the future. That's the point!

That's the whole story!!!!!!

In fact, Eckhart Tolle, the author of the best selling book "The Power of Now" is written about this phenomenon, living in our thoughts, ego and past experiences. And that only conscious living, to awaken to the present moment, can correct it.

The character, Joe Banks is modeled after Joseph Banks Rhine, the Duke University professor who was the founder of ESP and helped develop the field of parapsychology. He was also the first scientist to proclaim that man has a "soul". He hypothesize that we all have latent psychic abilities, a sixth sense, that we are only now discovering. And these psychic, mental abilities, that allow us to communicate with our minds, outside our physically bodies, is evidence of our spiritual nature.

John Patrick Shanley knew that most people would not get the message of this film and he depicted it in the movie when the ship was going down. Patricia was sending out distress SOS signals, that no one was receiving, and she announced to Joe " No one is getting this"

Watch this movie again with a fresh pair of eyes and openness to its message. Its brilliant!!!

To your Success, Frank Nicoletti, author of "You're the Best".c2001

reply

Thank you for that, hawk. I always loved this movie and felt that it had more meaning than many people gave it credit for. You made me want to watch it this afternoon now!

reply

"Take me to the volcano!"

reply

What a great interpretation, Hawk10. Thanks for that!

You--lighten up. You--big trouble. You--get in the car.

reply

I've never understood why this movie is not considered a 'classic'. When I saw it on release I said to a friend, this is one of those films that no one will like on release but will become a classic in 10 years time. Well, it's 18 years later - what's up with every one? This is a classic!


He's a semi-aquatic, egg-laying, mammal of action

reply

This film has been with me since I saw it at the theater (on a whim, I might add) in spring 1990.

It still speaks to me on so many levels--I agree that you have to "look closer" (to coin a phrase from another movie--American Beauty--which I felt borrowed many elements from Joe). The current rating on IMDb is 5.3. Why is there so much hate for this film? It's almost as if people are really afraid of "waking up."

I love the film--it brings tears to my eyes every time. I'd love to get the soundtrack some day.

DICK JONES! I WORK FOR DICK JONES!

reply

I love this movie too, and I'm not sure I can explain why. There are a lot of scenes and lines that have stuck with me - "I know he can get the job, but can he DO the job?" "I have no response for that." The moon rising over the raft with Elvis' dreamy "Blue Moon" - great stuff. I laughed almost all the way through when I first saw the movie, something that has never happened before or since - it really got to me on some fundamental level. It hasn't had that effect on me since, but then I suppose I've gotten more cynical over the years. I still love it, though, and I've always been astonished by the rough treatment it got from critics. Definitely underrated, even here.

I've been looking for a soundtrack too. Haven't had any luck. The song being played over the closing credits is just gorgeous, really moving. I know the music is by Georges Delerue. Nothing at amazon or ebay. I'm sure a soundtrack album exists, somewhere ... Keep looking!

And keep believing!

reply

Hello Katz5

The soundtrack is available, although it has a very limited production of about 3000 cd's.

You can find it for sale occasionally on ebay.

Good Luck!

Frank Nicoletti

reply

After such a long time, the soundtrack is available. "Marooned Without You" is worth every penny.

reply

Really great review of this movie. I had just earlier today decided to check out the wiki article on this movie. I didn't realize that the screenplay was written by someone who had had his own near-death experience and was trying to get that across to the audience. It's just a sweet and humorous movie that I think a lot of people miss the underlying message and the symbolism (I also didn't realize all the symbols in the movie until you pointed them out).

I'm going to have to watch this again with fresh eyes.

reply

Early costuming work of Colleen Atwood who would later win two Oscars for Chicago and Memoirs of a Geisha.

reply

Well, yes.

This movie is an existential masterpiece, and it will be known as such in time. Movies this well structured with such an important "message" and that deal with such important themes do not remain unknown forever.

The themes it deals with are not exactly easy to deal with in the language of a movie, but this movie succeeds and in spades.

Plus, it's just a fun movie to watch. Every single bit of acting in the movie is spot-on and has just the right amount of whimsy and sadness in it to be effective.

This movie is IMPORTANT, no question.

reply

When Patricia halts the ceremony to declare her love for Joe, the Waponi Chief gets an impatient look. Not just because it's delaying the ceremony, but because those who are focused on their own world, their own needs, have no patience for anything that happens outside of those needs, no matter how significant it might be. Just as Joe didn't see thousands of moonrises in his life, the Chief can't see the honesty of Patricia's declaration.

We could start a separate thread on the Waponi love of a commercial product (in an hysterical oil-can size). In the middle of nowhere, no television, no slick print ads, (no stores!) not only do they have to have their orange soda -- they have to have their favorite brand of orange soda. Beautiful!

Like everyone else here, I see and love the deeper movie. And let's not overlook Meg Ryan in that dress. Hubba.

reply

Hawk that was one of the best analyst of film I've ever read on the IMDB, thanks for sharing. 10/10

Look at the night sky, where does it end?
http://imdb.com/mymovies/list?l=15368636

reply

Hey Riotboy-

Thank you for sharing your honest feedback and movie list of your top rated films.

All the Best,
Frank Nicoletti

reply